i do apologise.......... some people just got my goat.
upscaling is a nuke ? cwikey then people better just accept what they are
given.
10/10 for originality because obviously switching to sd in hd got the desired
result on behalf of the programmes producers. playing with technology.
and once again apoligies for spoiling. thought the whole plot had been spoiled
by the first 5 or 6 mins and people couldnt watch the rest.
please tell me if i'm sarcastic and apart from one thing did i give it away. ??
aw shucks, watch up & shut up. did you complain when jaws went 3d ? i did.
stop complaining guys.
Shephard
Posted at 11/05/2008, 19:00
Quote by fuffer
i must agree! although she was emerged in a milky bubble bath (can't see much
there) and talked gibberish, she struck me as the most appealing actress in the
episode (whole season almost).
don't know why .. but in a very strange way, i find the hybrid woman quite
attractive and it's not only the actress being obviously hot, but something
else too. maybe the tone of her voice, when she speaks the most
important part. that moment truly gave me chills.
great show
lan-di
Posted at 11/05/2008, 20:09
Quote by fuffer
@munkybutt: spoilers, trolling... gtfo
@lan-di: hm, thanks for the info. if i remember right, there's a scene rule
that states downscaling to clearly specified resolutions (plus minus a few
pixels and some minor ar distortion) is ok but upscaling is reason for a
nuke.
it doesn't matter what the scene rules say. since aaf did an internal release,
it can't be nuked. it's something like unnoficial release ;p
they could have upscaled it but they din't. anyway, it doesn't really matter.
two more days patience for skyone's broadcast.
i've learned that it's a superb episode and i don't want to watch it pixeled. i
watched season3 on dsr and to be honest, i din't enjoyd it.
mrperfecto
Posted at 11/05/2008, 20:12
Quote by tooboodoo
Quote by zank
not much i can say other than most everyone agrees
it is worse than
the prior releases by other groups.
it
isn't great, but what 350 rip is?
i think 350 mb is very good. almost every 350 mb file is almost dvd quality. so
with that comment there you actually think dvd is bad or am i understanding you
incorrect?
pharmacopaeia
Posted at 11/05/2008, 20:14
bitch, moan, rinse, repeat.
i'm v happy with it - thank you uploader.
MAGNETRON
Posted at 12/05/2008, 09:08
d/l on the weekend down in oz and you say it not good quality then you expect to
much for free. yes the first part was as it was but i took it as a special
effect and enjoyed the episode with out complaint. so don't complain about
something for free (get over it) are you going to keep this for ever on your
(cd) oops old stuff dvd or your blue ray media, it doesn't last as long as they
say anyway. i backup to dvd and would be surprised if i got less than 5% fail in
a few years nobody even the manufactures have tested or that long yet. lol they
all say their media lasts x years but it doesn't. so watch it and forget then
reminisce
regards to the uploader thx
from the land of ozi. w australia
mulder
Posted at 13/05/2008, 00:00
i downloaded it and i couldn't see anything wrong with it at all. i don't know
what you people are whinging and bitching about. you should be greatful that
someone out there makes these available to you to download. if you watch it live
and you get a glitch do you ring the broadcasting company and complain? i bet
you don't. get a life!
mulder
Tooboodoo
Posted at 13/05/2008, 08:29
Quote by mrperfecto
i think 350 mb is very good. almost every 350 mb file is
almost dvd quality. so with that comment there you actually think dvd is bad or
am i understanding you incorrect?
no, you're understanding me correctly. dvd is 480i, which just isn't a great
resolution these days, especially on a 1080p screen; even with upconversion.
that being said, i find most 350 rips to be perfectly acceptable even when
upscaled to 1080p. hence all my arguing for the quality of this particular rip,
because as i've said (and others have said), there's really no problem with it.
as for skyone hd rips, for the most part they're not as enjoyable to me because
it seems like in the conversion process, either from ntsc to pal, or the
reverse, or something else, the audio (and framerate) is sped up to about 102%
of the us broadcast -- i watched the entire first season on skyone rips, and had
to actually decrease the playback speed to get the voices to sound normal.
either way, i've got the 350mb rip, and the 1.1gb rip, and i'm sure i'll check
out the skyone rip when it becomes available... and eventually i'll delete the
files when season 4 comes out on dvd. and then when they come out on bluray i'll
probably repeat the process. only for shows i love!
and it's not only the actress being obviously hot, but something
